The Black Hole of Hiring: Why Major Job Portals Are Failing Talent and Companies

9/12/2025

By Abhijitlal Pallath

The Black Hole of Hiring: Why Major Job Portals Are Failing Talent and Companies

TL;DR

Job portals overwhelm seekers with keyword games and silence, while employers drown in unqualified resumes. Quantity-over-quality platforms block real connections between talent and companies.

The digital age promised to revolutionise the way we find work and build teams. Giant job portals emerged as the bustling marketplaces of the 21st century, connecting ambitious professionals with innovative companies. Yet, for many, this promise has soured. Instead of a streamlined path to the perfect match, these platforms have become a convoluted labyrinth of frustration for both job seekers and hiring managers. The very tools designed to connect us are, in many ways, driving the right talent and the best companies further apart.

The Job Seeker’s Struggle

For job seekers, the experience is often a demoralising numbers game. Days are spent meticulously tailoring resumes and cover letters, only to submit them into a digital void, a so-called "black hole" from which feedback rarely escapes. The pressure to pepper applications with the "right" keywords to appease algorithms often overshadows the genuine articulation of skills and experience. The result? A soul-crushing cycle of applying for dozens, sometimes hundreds, of jobs with little to no response, leaving top talent feeling overlooked and undervalued.

The Employer’s Dilemma

On the other side of the screen, hiring companies are drowning in a sea of mediocrity. A single job posting can trigger an avalanche of applications, many of which are from candidates who are clearly unqualified. Recruiters and hiring managers are forced to spend countless hours sifting through this digital slush pile, their valuable time consumed by the sheer volume rather than the quality of applicants. This inefficiency not only inflates the cost-per-hire but also significantly delays the process of finding the right person for the role, leaving critical positions unfilled for longer.

The Core Problem

The core of the problem lies in the outdated, one-size-fits-all approach of many major job portals. They have become bloated, prioritising quantity over quality and ad revenue over genuine connection. The user experience is often clunky and impersonal, failing to capture the nuances of a candidate's potential or a company's unique culture. Great companies with incredible opportunities get lost in the noise, while talented individuals miss out on their dream jobs simply because they didn't use the perfect combination of keywords.

Moving Forward

The issues with major job portals highlight a critical need for smarter, more human-centered hiring solutions. By focusing on quality over quantity, understanding candidate potential, and fostering genuine connections, both job seekers and companies can finally escape the digital black hole. That is why we built Reach — a platform designed to connect top talent with the right opportunities efficiently and effectively, prioritizing meaningful matches over endless applications.

Download Reach and start finding the right opportunities today.